I spend my working day devising ways of consolidating people's identities in order to help them minimise the number of UserIDs/Passwords they have to remember and in order to help them portray a consistent online "persona".
I have to admit that I have assumed that this is what people want. But is it?
It would seem that the younger generation are more fickle than that. The BBC, in a recent "bill board" article (available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/6234663.stm), reported that research in the US suggests that teenagers are happy to ditch their UserIDs or eMail Addresses in favour of new ones on a quite random basis.
Indeed, it would also seem that they are quite keen on having multiple identities portraying very different personalities. This, I can understand. After all, I have my "Identity Management Consultant" persona online in the form of this blog but I also have my "Sporting Athlete" persona online in the form of my hockey club website (available at http://www.eastantrim.co.uk/). I am very much the same person but the personality I portray through each is very different.
I can also understand that teenagers don't know who they are and will constantly change their online identity until they find an identity that they feel comfortable with. Maybe I have aged sufficiently to either be happy with my current identity or just too busy to attempt to alter it.
I will readily admit to having had the same email address and the same phone number for as long as I can remember. The kids at my hockey club seem to change both quite regularly.
So, maybe the world of Identity Management has a new challenge. Maybe there are users who would be horrified at the thought of only having a single identity? Thankfully for those users, Identity Management is still struggling to gain momentum within the enterprise world. The world where multiple identities are common place (and where those users live) is a social world within which Identity Management is not yet welcome. Does anyone remember Microsoft Passport?
In a world where technology is supposed to make things simpler, why is it that the world seems to be more complicated? This blog is made up of the ramblings of an IT Security Consultant specialising in IBM Security software with a heavy focus on IGI, ITIM/ISIM, ITAM/ISAM and ITDI/ISDI. All opinions expressed are my own and have nothing to do with any employer past or present. I hope you find them useful.
Monday, January 08, 2007
Sunday, December 31, 2006
Identity Theft
It's New Year's Eve (or Old Year's Night as we like to call it) and yet my thoughts are focussed on Identity Fraud/Theft. Why?
Yesterday, a credit card statement turned up - post Christmas credit card statements are grim! Stuffed into the envelope was a leaflet informing me of the growing problem of identity theft. Of course there were the usual helpful tips on keeping your identity safe: shred your statements & use different passwords for each of the websites you visit. It was a gripping read.
But I also got a letter addressed to my 2 year old daughter from another financial institution advising her that Identity Theft was on the rise. It too had similar hints and tips for Identity Theft prevention.
The two institutions that sent these leaflets were purpoting to be eager to help my daughter and I the combat against Identity Theft. Of course, this assistance would be provided for a small monthly charge - what cost your identity after all. I must admit, though, that I struggled to see what these companies were actually doing for the money that they were demanding.
Of course, these companies are relying on our fears and perpetuating the notion that the world is a dangerous place. Of course it is... but one of the safest places to be is in an electronic world. I feel quite safe purchasing goods with a credit card via the wonder of the internet with reputable suppliers. I feel quite safe looking after my financial affairs online. And I still believe that if someone is going to steal my identity, they won't necessarily do it online - they will do it the old-fashioned way.
"The old-fashioned way?" I hear some of you say, "surely identity theft is a new phenomonen?"
Of course it isn't and the online world hasn't made it that much easier really. Those that fall foul of phishing attacks are likely to be the same people that fall foul of more traditional cons. (To understand the traditional cons, "The Real Hustle" on the BBC is a very good series showing how it is done).
So will I be parting with my hard earned cash in order to protect my identity? Nope... I'll look after my identity myself by being vigilant.
Happy New Year....
Yesterday, a credit card statement turned up - post Christmas credit card statements are grim! Stuffed into the envelope was a leaflet informing me of the growing problem of identity theft. Of course there were the usual helpful tips on keeping your identity safe: shred your statements & use different passwords for each of the websites you visit. It was a gripping read.
But I also got a letter addressed to my 2 year old daughter from another financial institution advising her that Identity Theft was on the rise. It too had similar hints and tips for Identity Theft prevention.
The two institutions that sent these leaflets were purpoting to be eager to help my daughter and I the combat against Identity Theft. Of course, this assistance would be provided for a small monthly charge - what cost your identity after all. I must admit, though, that I struggled to see what these companies were actually doing for the money that they were demanding.
Of course, these companies are relying on our fears and perpetuating the notion that the world is a dangerous place. Of course it is... but one of the safest places to be is in an electronic world. I feel quite safe purchasing goods with a credit card via the wonder of the internet with reputable suppliers. I feel quite safe looking after my financial affairs online. And I still believe that if someone is going to steal my identity, they won't necessarily do it online - they will do it the old-fashioned way.
"The old-fashioned way?" I hear some of you say, "surely identity theft is a new phenomonen?"
Of course it isn't and the online world hasn't made it that much easier really. Those that fall foul of phishing attacks are likely to be the same people that fall foul of more traditional cons. (To understand the traditional cons, "The Real Hustle" on the BBC is a very good series showing how it is done).
So will I be parting with my hard earned cash in order to protect my identity? Nope... I'll look after my identity myself by being vigilant.
Happy New Year....
Friday, December 22, 2006
Time for Fun!
It's the last working day before Christmas and therefore the time to ensure that everything is in order for the holiday period.
More importantly, it's time for some "resting" and fun.
My friends and I had great fun this morning discussing the results of the Hobbit Name Generator which can be found at http://www.chriswetherell.com/hobbit/ - it is well worth a 5 minute visit.
My Hobbit name is "Mungo Loamsdown of Deephallow" with which I'm quite pleased. We were also particularly impressed with "Minto Hamwich of Buckleberry Fern".
We all have a name yet we are known by various names & identities depending on who is addressing us. I respond to the following:
Nah... I'll always be either a son, daddy or husband. But there must be a chance that the number of identities I own can be reduced significantly. The utopian world which includes an Identity Provider as a service which can be utilised by all these various systems sounds great (if a little dangerous if it were ever compromised). The world of security federation is just around the corner and I for one can't wait - my brain is stuffed to capacity with UserIDs and Passwords!
In the meantime, I might just change all my UserIDs to "Mungo Loamsdown" :-)
Merry Christmas everyone...
More importantly, it's time for some "resting" and fun.
My friends and I had great fun this morning discussing the results of the Hobbit Name Generator which can be found at http://www.chriswetherell.com/hobbit/ - it is well worth a 5 minute visit.
My Hobbit name is "Mungo Loamsdown of Deephallow" with which I'm quite pleased. We were also particularly impressed with "Minto Hamwich of Buckleberry Fern".
We all have a name yet we are known by various names & identities depending on who is addressing us. I respond to the following:
- Stephen (and sometimes Steve)
- Sir
- Son
- Daddy
- Mr. Swann
- Oi You
- (and now Mungo Loamsdown)
- At my bank, I am a number.
- On my blog, I am an email address.
- At work, I am a combination of letters and numerals.
- On my web based training site, I am a nickname.
Nah... I'll always be either a son, daddy or husband. But there must be a chance that the number of identities I own can be reduced significantly. The utopian world which includes an Identity Provider as a service which can be utilised by all these various systems sounds great (if a little dangerous if it were ever compromised). The world of security federation is just around the corner and I for one can't wait - my brain is stuffed to capacity with UserIDs and Passwords!
In the meantime, I might just change all my UserIDs to "Mungo Loamsdown" :-)
Merry Christmas everyone...
Tuesday, December 19, 2006
My Poor Wallet
I have a Samsonite wallet that I bought at Heathrow a few years ago. Upon opening it today, however, I noticed that it was torn and will need replaced - which sounds like a good Christmas present if ever there was one.
The problem, as I see it, is that the wallet is stuffed full of cards and has been under considerable straing for far too long:
Almost all of these cards have a chip on them - I'm guessing a lot of them are only single-function chips, unfortunately. I say unfortunately because if I could in someway amalgamate the functions of these cards, then I wouldn't be in the position of having to replace my wallet!
Why can't we live in a world whereby I have a single card which has a chip capable of:
An identity provider/service provider model would certainly ease the strain on my poor wallet. In the meantime, I will have to continue carrying the lorryload of cards I need to go about my daily business.
The problem, as I see it, is that the wallet is stuffed full of cards and has been under considerable straing for far too long:
- 4 credit cards
- 2 debit cards
- 3 hotel loyalty cards
- 2 air operator loyalty cards
- 6 store loyalty cards
Almost all of these cards have a chip on them - I'm guessing a lot of them are only single-function chips, unfortunately. I say unfortunately because if I could in someway amalgamate the functions of these cards, then I wouldn't be in the position of having to replace my wallet!
Why can't we live in a world whereby I have a single card which has a chip capable of:
- identifying myself for cash withdrawal
- recording my spending habits (and thus accumulate cashback points from my various "suppliers")
- identifying myself when gaining access to airport lounges
An identity provider/service provider model would certainly ease the strain on my poor wallet. In the meantime, I will have to continue carrying the lorryload of cards I need to go about my daily business.
Monday, December 18, 2006
Practical RFID
I remember proposing to the Chief Architect at my company that we should be looking into how RFID might help our sales teams in our branch network.
How so?
Well... Picture the scene. A customer goes to their Bank's branch to lodge a cheque. While standing in the queue, they lift a brochure detailing the benefits of taking out an insurance policy or investing in the latest "fund".
If the brochure is tagged using the latest RFID technology, when the customer finally arrives at the teller position, the teller will now be armed with some vital information: the customer's details and their interest in other products. What a powerful position to be in! The teller could either log the information (or it could be logged automatically) or the teller could broach the subject of the product in question with the customer.
At the time, the Chief Architect was very interested although I'm not sure he was convinced that the technology would actually work. In short... it was not a visionary at all.
And therein lies the question. Is the role of IT within the enterprise solely to deliver on business requirements or is it there to help define opportunities for the business. Personally, I believe the guys in IT wouldn't be doing their job properly if they weren't spending some of their time investigating new opportunites. Unfortunately, the Cost Centre approach to enterprises doesn't really allow for this type of research.
Does anybody remember the days when we used to be called "Research & Development"? (Google employees need not answer that question - I'm really quite jealous of you!)
How so?
Well... Picture the scene. A customer goes to their Bank's branch to lodge a cheque. While standing in the queue, they lift a brochure detailing the benefits of taking out an insurance policy or investing in the latest "fund".
If the brochure is tagged using the latest RFID technology, when the customer finally arrives at the teller position, the teller will now be armed with some vital information: the customer's details and their interest in other products. What a powerful position to be in! The teller could either log the information (or it could be logged automatically) or the teller could broach the subject of the product in question with the customer.
At the time, the Chief Architect was very interested although I'm not sure he was convinced that the technology would actually work. In short... it was not a visionary at all.
And therein lies the question. Is the role of IT within the enterprise solely to deliver on business requirements or is it there to help define opportunities for the business. Personally, I believe the guys in IT wouldn't be doing their job properly if they weren't spending some of their time investigating new opportunites. Unfortunately, the Cost Centre approach to enterprises doesn't really allow for this type of research.
Does anybody remember the days when we used to be called "Research & Development"? (Google employees need not answer that question - I'm really quite jealous of you!)
A Difficult Year
I can't believe it has been a year since I last posted!
The year has been a tremendously difficult one with many low points. The main low was the realisation that major technical decisions within organisations are rarely made by people who actually understand technology. Why didn't I previously understand this? Naiviety?
It would seem that the decision making process is typically a process which is based on the following:
So can people really make a difference in an enterprise? Of course they can, but only if they are prepared to play the game. There's little point in complaining about the decision making process - no amount of complaining is going to change anything! Instead, working from within the system is likely to reap greater rewards.
Unfortunately, it can be seen how the destructive decision making process described above becomes self-perpetuating - it's the only way to get things done!
Of course... I'm not necessarily talking about my own organisation!
On a positive note... I did manage to pass an exam recently which allows me to display the following image:
The year has been a tremendously difficult one with many low points. The main low was the realisation that major technical decisions within organisations are rarely made by people who actually understand technology. Why didn't I previously understand this? Naiviety?
It would seem that the decision making process is typically a process which is based on the following:
- Political manouevring
- Self-interest
- Self-promotion
- Self-interest
- and Self-interest
So can people really make a difference in an enterprise? Of course they can, but only if they are prepared to play the game. There's little point in complaining about the decision making process - no amount of complaining is going to change anything! Instead, working from within the system is likely to reap greater rewards.
Unfortunately, it can be seen how the destructive decision making process described above becomes self-perpetuating - it's the only way to get things done!
Of course... I'm not necessarily talking about my own organisation!
On a positive note... I did manage to pass an exam recently which allows me to display the following image:
Sunday, September 11, 2005
Who Are You Anyway
I'm particularly interested in understanding how technology can help identify people. Identity Management is a "buzz-phrase" that has been on the go for a couple of years and lots of very talented people/organisations are trying to join up their thinking with regards to the problems posed by "identification".
Are the enterprises up to speed?
Yes and no. The techies often have an understanding of the problem and a view of how to solve the problem. The rest of the organisation still thinks IM means instant messaging!
How do you identify your customer - User ID and Password? That's one way - not very reliable though. Iris scanning? That's another way and the technology is improving all the time - bit expensive though.
My organisation is a financial institution and as such we can identify our customers by:
Are the enterprises up to speed?
Yes and no. The techies often have an understanding of the problem and a view of how to solve the problem. The rest of the organisation still thinks IM means instant messaging!
How do you identify your customer - User ID and Password? That's one way - not very reliable though. Iris scanning? That's another way and the technology is improving all the time - bit expensive though.
My organisation is a financial institution and as such we can identify our customers by:
- User ID, Password and Shared Secret Q&A
- Credit/Debit Card and PIN
- User ID, Password and Location ID on a direct link ISDN line
- Signatures
- Photographic lookup (just like passport control)
- Smart Card
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)