Thursday, September 26, 2013

ITIM Best Practices For Workflow Design

It sounds rather arrogant to call this blog entry "Best Practices" when it is merely my meandering thoughts that I'm about to spew forth. But a number of experiences of other people's work recently has almost moved me to tears.

So here is my list of "best practices".

Workflow Start Nodes

The Start Node (and the End Node for that matter) is not somewhere that code should be placed. Code can be placed in these nodes, of course. But it shouldn't ever be placed in here. For example, how could I know that the following Workflow has been customised:



If you have code that needs to be run as soon as the workflow starts, place a Script Node immediately after the Start Node and name it appropriately. This is MUCH better:



Script Node Size

If I open a Script Node and find that there are 1,000 lines of code in there, I will cry. If you have 1,000 lines of code you are probably doing something wrong. I would much rather see multiple Script Nodes with a sensible name describing their function laid out in an organised manner that gives me a good visual representation of the process rather than having to wade through hundreds or thousands of lines of code.

Workflow Extensions

If you have written some Javascript that looks cool and funky and re-usable, then make it cool and funky and re-usable by creating a Workflow Extension. Also, feel free to give extensions back to the community! (I shall publish some of my favourites soon!)

Hardcoding!

If I see a hardcoded erglobalid reference in a Script Node, I will, in all possibility, hunt the developer down and do very un-Tivolian things to him or her. Their assumption that their code will work when promoted through various environments is very flawed and they are being lazy. Do Not Hardcode!

Commenting & Logging
You might think your code is readable, but the chances are that it could still do with some comments here and there. Even if the code is understandable, the reasoning behind performing the function may not be so clear and requirements documents and design documents have a habit of disappearing!

When it comes to logging, log appropriately and update the status of the workflow throughout the workflow process. The following statements are great to see in Script Nodes because we can successfully handle any problems and ensure that we always navigate our way to the End Node.

activity.setResult(activity.SUCCESS, "Attributes Successfully Verified");
activity.setResult(activity.FAILED, "Attribute Verification Failed due to " + errMsg);

And Finally

The chances are that someone will come along after you have done all your hard work and they will look at your workflow. Do you want them to cry? Or do you want them to be delighted in what they have seen? Make sure you delight people!

Friday, June 07, 2013

Careful Where You Point That Finger

Over the last 9 months, I have managed to shed almost 50lbs in weight - that in excess of 20Kg for those living in the metric world. As part of the process of losing weight, I took to tracking my walking and cycling habits using Endomondo on my phone - and what an excellent piece of software that is.

I did have a problem, though!

When I started the application and enabled GPS, I would wait quite a considerably amount of time before my location could be determined. Indeed, I had completed the bulk of some of my journeys by the time I got the "GPS Excellent" notification.

Initially, my thoughts went along these lines:

"Endomondo have coded their freebie application to not pick up my location in the hope that I will purchase the Pro version of their app"

I did purchase the Pro version - mostly because I thought the app was terrific with only a slight nod towards the hope that my GPS issues would be resolved. My GPS issues weren't resolved.

So I then thought:

"I must have dropped my phone at some point and 'disturbed' its ability to perform it's GPS magic"

This seemed like a reasonable thought as all my friends and colleagues and perfectly acceptable Endomondo experiences on their phones. Indeed, my Samsung Galaxy II seemed to be really struggling when compared to a colleague's Nexus - and they were both Android phones.

I figured it must be time for a new phone. And proceeded to spend the next couple of weeks evaluating my options. And then... I woke up one morning to discover that my phone wanted to apply an update to my Android operating system.

An hour or so later, I had a shiny new OS. Admittedly, performance was awful initially as all my apps needed updating too. And, all my icons had been resorted alphabetically (for which I could quite happily exact some kind of tortuous revenge on the developer of the upgrade process). Apart from the initial dodgy performance and the tears that followed the pain of re-organising my icons, I noticed two things:
  • Playing 7x7 was super-fast - 7x7 is one of those simple yet addictive games that can keep me going for hours
  • GPS performance was perfect!

Wonderful! When starting Endomondo Pro now, I have to wait no longer than 2 or 3 seconds before I have my "GPS Excellent" notification. And to think my problems were with the app or the phone.

So. What's the point of this story I hear you ask! Well, it is far too easy to make a judgement about an app, or a product or almost anything you might encounter during the course of your life. My problems had nothing to do with Endomondo's developers' coding ability; nor had it anything to do with how Samsung hardware technicians had put my phone together. Yet, even for a techie like me, my thought processes led me to think bad thoughts about both!

I have seen senior managers in enterprises make some very strange decisions in the past. They may decide that they no longer need "Huge Software Developer's Amazing IT Solution" because it costs too much and doesn't perform the way they expected and instead by "Enormous Software Developer's Stupendous IT Solution" in the anticipation that it will cost less and perform perfectly.

And frequently, I don't see the cost benefit and the performance problems still exist.

Sometimes the problems we are faced with in the IT world are not being caused by the applications we are using. Sometimes we need to dig a little deeper to find out what the real cause of a problem is - whether it be the hardware platform we are using; the operating system in use; the networking setup; the interfaces; and of course, the users and their expectations.

And finally... maybe some of the big boys can learn from the developers of the apps we now use on a daily basis on our smartphones. Endomondo does exactly what I need in a manner which makes sense for me. Can we say the same thing for enterprise software?

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Tempus Fugit

I remember being a follower of a blogger who wrote about IBM Tivoli security solutions and becoming quite concerned for his well being when he "stopped" blogging for a while. When he had gone fully six months without blogging, I had myself convinced that something terrible had happened to him personally.

And now I find that I have done the same thing. My periodical briefings have stopped. But fear not - it's not because of any ill health. It's not because of a change in career. It's not even to do with boredom. It has everything to do with being far too busy and that's the best reason of all for the temporary blip in my output.

But, time flies... and too much time has passed since I last committed my thoughts to writing.

So what has happened since in the last 6 months? Well, the IBM Tivoli re-branding exercise is in full swing with IBM Security Identity Manager and IBM Security Access Manager products having been released.

And what has changed in those products?

ISAM has a brand new deployment process which is greatly simplified. However, for TAMeb users who have deployed their software on Windows, beware? The upgrade process might not behave as you expect? Why? The move to a 64-bit architecture, that's why? Think seriously about any attempt to perform an in-situ upgrade!

You might like to also check compression settings on your WebSEALs - a respected colleague of mine has already encountered some fun and games with those!

And ISIM? Is it just a pure re-branding exercise? Not at all. Some functional additions are definitely welcome like the controls added to the services offering retry operations on failed resources. Account ownership and role attributes look interesting (despite how they have been implemented). Privileged Identity Management is a great addition as is the inclusion of supported web services API.

But core processing that ITIM administrators will know and love is still there!

And what of my work recently? Well, it's a matter of spending a lot of time concentrating on federated security, and environmental upgrades. Working on pre-sales; sprucing up designs; sizing projects; and helping those around me get best use out of their IBM Tivoli/Security solutions.

So much has happened in recent months, though, that I hardly know where to start in documenting it all. There has been fun with SAML v2. Flirtations with FESI extension re-writes. Dalliances with web services and APIs. Encounters with business process re-engineering.

My next article, however, will likely be an IBM Tivoli Directory Integrator article centred on best practice for collaborative development. That sounds like a tricky one!